Effect of Criteria Range on the Similarity of Results in the COMET Method

Defining input values in the decision-making process can be done with appropriate methods or based on expert knowledge. It is essential to ensure that the values are adequate for the problem to be solved in both cases. There may be situations where values are overestimated, and it should be checked whether this affects the final results. In this paper, the Characteristic Objects Method (COMET) was used to investigate the overestimation effect on the final rankings. The decision matrixes with a different number of alternatives and criteria were assessed The obtained results were compared using the WS similarity coefficient and Spearman's weighted correlation coefficient. The study showed that overestimation has a significant effect on the rankings. A larger number of criteria has a positive effect on the correlation strength of the compared rankings. In contrast, a large overestimation of characteristic values has a negative effect on the similarity of the results.

---

1. The work was supported by the National Science Centre, Decision number UMO-2018/29/B/HS4/02725 (W.S.).

---

2. Track 3: Advances in Information Systems and Technology

---

3. Session: 16th Conference on Information Systems Management

---

4. Short Papers