Tytuł pozycji:
Neglecting others and making it up to them : the idea of a corrective duty
- Tytuł:
-
Neglecting others and making it up to them : the idea of a corrective duty
- Autorzy:
-
Fornaroli, Giulio
- Data publikacji:
-
2023
- Język:
-
angielski
- ISBN, ISSN:
-
13523252
- Prawa:
-
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode.pl
Udzielam licencji. Uznanie autorstwa 4.0 Międzynarodowa
- Dostawca treści:
-
Repozytorium Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego
-
I aspire to answer two questions regarding the concept of a corrective duty. The first concerns what it means to wrong others, thus triggering a demand for corrections (the ground question). The second relates to the proper content of corrective duties. I first illustrate how three prominent accounts of corrective duties - the Aristotelian model of correlativity, the Kantian idea that wronging corresponds to the violation of others’ right to freedom, and the more recent continuity view - have failed to answer the two questions satisfactorily. I then introduce my proposal, which holds that we wrong others when we
fail to treat their status as moral agents as a source of stringent constraints on our action. I call it the moral neglect account. Once we have identified a common aim of corrective duties (counterbalancing moral neglect), we can fill their content in the various contexts in which wronging has occurred. I conclude by observing that it is not the primary role of corrective justice to assign responsibilities for damage reparations; in fact, requests for compensation make more sense if framed in distributive rather than corrective terms.